Skip to the page
Compare quotes from local specialists in Sacramento
SACRAMENTO HEATING AND AC Get my quote
Outdoor heat pump beside a gas meter on a house wall

Guide ยท Sacramento

Heat pump vs gas furnace

A heat pump heats and cools with electricity, and a gas furnace heats by burning fuel and needs a separate air conditioner. This guide compares cost, comfort, cooling and repairs so you can ask local specialists the right questions.

Revised

A heat pump is usually the better fit when you want one system to heat and cool and your winters are mild. A gas furnace is the better fit when you want a separate, familiar heat source or already have a gas line and ducts in good shape. Neither is right for every house. The U.S. Department of Energy says modern air-source heat pumps can reduce electricity use by 50 percent compared with electric furnaces and electric baseboard heaters. That comparison is with electric resistance heating, not with gas. This comparison sits next to our guide to heat pump repair and covers cost, comfort, cooling and what breaks.

How does each one heat your home?

A gas furnace burns natural gas in a burner, passes the heat through a heat exchanger and blows warm air through the ducts. A heat pump uses electricity to move heat instead of making it. The Department of Energy says it works like a refrigerator: in winter it moves heat from outdoors into the home, and in summer it moves heat from the home outdoors.

That reversal is why one heat pump does both jobs. A gas furnace only heats, so a house with one also has a separate central air conditioner, usually sharing the same ducts and blower. Heat pumps come as ducted systems and as ductless mini-splits; our page on mini split AC covers the ductless type.

Do heat pumps work in Sacramento winters?

Often, yes. In a climate like this one they are a reasonable option to price. NOAA's 1991-2020 normals for Sacramento Executive Airport put the average January low at about 39.2 F and the July average high at about 92.6 F. That is mild for winter and hot for summer, which suits a system that does both jobs.

Heat pump with light frost on a winter morning

The Department of Energy says newer air-source heat pumps are now a legitimate option for colder regions, which were once off limits. A heat pump loses some heating capacity as it gets colder, and some homes add backup electric heat for cold snaps. Ask the specialist how the unit you are quoted behaves at the coldest temperatures in your area.

How much does a heat pump cost compared with a gas furnace?

A heat pump costs more to install than a gas furnace alone, but it also replaces the air conditioner. Fixr puts heat pump installation at $5,000 to $15,000. There is no sourced range for a gas furnace alone or a central air conditioner alone, so ask for a written quote for each. Replacing both together, the furnace and the air conditioner, is $8,000 to $20,000 in Fixr's HVAC installation cost article.

System Sourced installed range
Heat pump installation (heat and cool) $5,000-15,000
Whole system replacement (furnace and AC) $8,000-20,000
Natural gas furnace alone (heat only) Ask for a written quote
Central air conditioner alone (cool only) Ask for a written quote

Prices differ by home size, ductwork condition, efficiency rating and the labor of the specialist you choose. New ducts, if needed, add to the total, so ask for them as a separate line. Get written estimates before you compare. Our page on heat pump cost breaks the range down further, and HVAC system installation cost covers the wider picture.

Which one costs less to run?

It depends on your gas and electricity prices and on the efficiency of the equipment, so no honest answer is the same for every house. The Department of Energy reports that air-source heat pumps can reduce electricity use by 50 percent compared with electric furnaces and electric baseboard heaters. That figure does not compare a heat pump with a gas furnace, and compared with a gas furnace the result depends on local rates.

For a furnace, look at the AFUE rating, which is the share of fuel that becomes heat. A higher AFUE is more efficient, so ask for the AFUE of the quoted model. For a heat pump and air conditioner, look at the SEER2 rating for cooling and the HSPF2 rating for heating. Ask each specialist to give you the ratings for the exact model and to estimate yearly running costs using your own bills.

What are the heat pump vs AC pros and cons?

An air conditioner only cools. A heat pump cools the same way and also heats, so you buy one outdoor unit instead of an air conditioner plus a furnace. The tradeoff is that a heat pump does both jobs, so ask the specialist how the unit is expected to be used and maintained through the year.

Heat pump pros

  • One system heats and cools.
  • Uses no on-site fuel, so no gas line, burner or flue.
  • Can lower electricity use compared with electric resistance heat.

Heat pump cons

  • Heating capacity falls as outdoor temperatures drop.
  • Higher upfront cost than a basic air conditioner.
  • May need electrical work, so ask what the quote includes.

Gas furnace pros

  • Familiar, widely serviced equipment.
  • Strong heat output in cold weather.

Gas furnace cons

  • Needs a gas line, venting and a heat exchanger that must stay sealed.
  • Cooling needs a separate air conditioner.

Is a heat pump better than an AC for cooling?

For cooling alone, a heat pump and a standard air conditioner perform much the same, because both use the same refrigerant cycle. Ratings are what matter, so compare SEER2 numbers, not the type of unit. Our page on AC vs heat pump goes into the choice in more detail.

If you have a working gas furnace and an old air conditioner, a matched replacement of just the air conditioner may cost less than switching. If both are old, a heat pump replaces two systems at once.

How long do they last, and what fails?

The Department of Energy's cost analyses assume a 15-year average life for a residential air-source heat pump and an average furnace lifetime of 21 years. Those are assumptions used for analysis, not promises for your equipment. Failures differ. Furnaces see failing ignitors, control boards, sensors and, over time, a cracked heat exchanger. Heat pumps share many air conditioner problems, such as a failing capacitor, a refrigerant leak or a compressor fault, plus a reversing valve that switches heating and cooling.

Regular service helps catch these early. Ask any specialist for heat pump repair prices up front, since they vary by part. If a unit is failing at 15 years, ask for a repair quote and a replacement quote. For furnaces, our pages on furnace repair and the heat exchanger explain the common faults.

What is the conclusion: which should you choose?

Choose a heat pump if you need to replace the air conditioner as well, want one system, and your electricity rates are reasonable. Choose a gas furnace if your furnace is fine, your ducts and gas line are in place and your air conditioner is newer. In both cases, get at least two written quotes that name the model, the efficiency rating, the size and what is included.

C-20 is the CSLB classification for warm-air heating, ventilating and air-conditioning work. Whichever system you choose, ask for the specialist's license number and check it on the CSLB License Check page of the California Contractors State License Board. You can also start at Sacramento Heating and AC or request quotes.

Get a price for your HVAC repair job

Fill this in and a local specialist gets back to you to quote.

So the business can look at the job and price it.

Questions people ask

How long does a heat pump vs gas furnace comparison take?

A comparison takes as long as it takes to get two or three written estimates. A specialist usually visits to measure and look at the ducts and panel, then sends a written quote. Ask each to price both options for your home.

What should I ask before I hire someone for a heat pump or furnace replacement?

Ask for their California contractor license number, the size and model, the SEER2 and HSPF2 or AFUE ratings, how they sized the system, whether new ducts or electrical work is needed, what permits apply, the written warranty and the total price. Compare the same scope in each quote.

Do I need to be home for a heat pump or furnace replacement?

Yes, an adult should be home for the visit to measure and again during installation. Ask each specialist how long the job will take, and plan for the heating or cooling to be off for part of that time, so choose a day when the weather is mild if you can.

Can a heat pump heat a house when it is cold?

Yes, within limits. Modern air-source heat pumps work in colder regions than older models, and the Sacramento January average low is about 39 F, so a correctly sized unit should cope. Cold nights below that may lower output, and some units add backup electric heat. Ask what backup the quote includes.

Do heat pumps need more repairs than furnaces?

Not necessarily. A heat pump does the work of both a furnace and an air conditioner, so it is one system to maintain instead of two. Fixr puts heat pump repair at $150-650, and regular service is a good way to catch faults early. Ask each specialist about parts they stock.

Where these facts come from

Page updated